A Charlotte Mason Education, Mason Charter Schools, Mason Schools
Comments 3

Mason for All: Gillingham Charter Reviewed by HollyAnne Dobbins


“Charlotte firmly believed that her liberal education ideas were applicable to all children regardless of class, status, or ability, and she put her ideas into practice, as she always did.”

~John Thorley, Foreword to School Education


After my wonderful trip to England last summer, I have found myself even more attached to the ideas and spirit of Charlotte Mason’s work in education. Thus, when Dr. Nola Stephens, Professor of English and Linguistics at Covenant College, announced to our Advanced Composition class this fall that we would be selecting our own topics for a semester-long research project, I immediately began investigating ways to incorporate Charlotte’s work into my own. With guidance from Dr. Beckman, I decided to research the methods and success of two charter schools: The Classical Academy and Gillingham Charter School. The Classical Academy is a large, established, and successful charter school in Colorado that utilizes some of Mason’s methods such as nature, picture, and composer studies. Gillingham, on the other hand, is located in Pennsylvania and is a small, new school just over a year and a half old. While my formal study was inconclusive regarding the success of Mason’s methods in charter schools, I thoroughly enjoyed learning more about Gillingham and becoming acquainted with its headmistress, Nicolle Hutchinson.

According to Pennsylvania’s Education Law Center, charter schools are public schools that are created by agreement with the local school board. They are free to attend and are open to all students. They are also required to comply with state and federal assessment laws. What sets them apart from other public schools, however, is that they are free to design their own curriculum and pedagogy. In fact, most charter schools adopt a particular philosophy of education (Koppich 1997).  Gillingham Charter School, at least to my knowledge, is the first and only fully Charlotte Mason public school in the United States.

Gillingham is seeking to fulfill Charlotte’s vision of making her ideas available and applicable to all children. The school faces many challenges along the way. First was the arduous task of designing a curriculum—many of us remember and even helped with that project. Now they continue to develop and “tweak” that curriculum as they teach. The school is under the watchful eye of the local government; it must meet Annual Yearly Progress (AYP; federal achievement standards assessed by high stakes testing) just like other public schools. Gillingham must also consider its parents and students. Charlotte Mason’s methods are new to many of the families in the school. Furthermore, many of the students came to Gillingham because they had struggled academically at their old schools or because they have special education needs. But Nicolle Hutchinson and her brave teachers believe that they can rise to these challenges and that Mason’s methods will be successful for all their students.

In the 2011-2012 school year, after only five months of instruction, Gillingham’s students took the standardized tests. Discouragingly, the school did not meet AYP. Still, they rallied their courage, “tweaked” the curriculum some more, and plunged bravely into the new school year (2012-2013). Wow! My research and interest in the school obviously cannot predict the future, but it has led me to have a deep admiration of Nicolle, her teachers, and the vision they share. In a country where we often bemoan the state of public education, they are seeking to work within the school system to love and educate children as persons. I think that we are going to see marvelous things happen at Gillingham over the next few years, things that show that Mason’s methods are not only person-building, but are also the basis for a strong education, even by strict standardized measurements. Please join me in keeping Nicolle and all of Gillingham in our prayers as they continue on this journey.


Merry Christmas, Everyone!


Works Cited

Education Law Center. (2008). Charter schools in Pennsylvania—Frequently asked questions. Retrieved

from http://www.gillinghamcharterschool.org/Investigating-Charter-Schools/

Koppich, J.E. (1997). Considering nontraditional alternatives: Charters, private contracts, and vouchers.

The Future of Children, 7(3), 96-111.

Thorley, J. (1989). Foreward. In Mason, Charlotte M. (1925). School education. Elkton, MD: Charlotte

Mason Research and Supply.

© 2012 HollyAnne Dobbins


Carroll Smith has spoken on various topics related to Charlotte Mason. Currently he teaches at Gardner-Webb University and enjoys working with children, teachers, college students, and Charlotte Mason Institute. He was a teacher and a principal for 21 years before coming to Gardner-Webb University where he has been for six years. Having grown up in eastern North Carolina, he attended East Carolina University for his undergraduate degree and his master's in school administration. He completed his terminal degree and wrote his dissertation on Charlotte Mason at Virginia Tech. Carroll enjoys reading, gardening, and discussing ideas with friends. He and his wife, Andra, and their two young adult college-age children, Corban and Anna, enjoy living, working and playing in North Carolina.


  1. Vicki Shanaghan says

    How does separation of church and state in pubic schools impact Gillingham?
    I can’t imagine a Charlotte Mason curriculum without God as the foundation.

    • HollyAnne says

      As with any other public school, Gillingham is not allowed to have any religious affiliation. Thus, while faith can independently influence the teachers’ understanding of Mason and their worldview, it cannot be taught in the classroom. Mason’s direct references to faith are also, therefore, excluded. Nicolle is far more the expert than I on the details of how this impacts their curriculum and the classrooms at Gillingham.

  2. Very encouraging. I think even as a homeschooler that my vision needs to reach beyond my family – for the children’s sake. One of the big drawcards to CM for me was her heart for children with all degrees of intelligence – even the backward, or those not so academically inclined are included.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s